Communication Center  Conference  Projects Share  Reports from the Field Resources  Library  LSC Project Websites  NSF Program Notes
 How to Use this site    Contact us  LSC-Net: Local Systemic Change Network
Educational Reform & Policy

Systemic Reform

Math Reform

Science Reform

Technology Integration


International Focus and TIMSS


Assessment and Accountability

School Culture

Public Engagement

Professional Development

Teaching and Learning

LSC Papers and Reports



The Limits of Sanctions in Low-Performing Schools: A Study of Maryland and Kentucky Schools on Probation

author: Heinrich Mintrop
description: This study focuses on how schools that have been labeled as "failing" respond to being placed on probation. It provides interesting "accounts" on the effect that probation has had on individual performance motivation, organizational processes, and patterns of instruction.

Abstract: "The article reports on a study of 11 schools that were labeled as low-performing by the state accountability systems of Maryland and Kentucky, nationally known for complex performance-based assessments. The study shows that putting schools on probation only weakly motivated teachers because the assessments were largely perceived as unfair, invalid, and unrealistic. Administrators responded with control strategies that rigidified organizations, forestalling dialog and learning processes. Instructional reform developed only feebly. On the other hand, some schools remedied inefficiencies and were able to "harvest the low-hanging fruit." The schools struggled with severe problems of teacher commitment."

URL link:
published in: Education Policy Analysis Archives
published: January 15, 2003
posted to site: 01/23/2003